>

Exploring the Debt & the Legacy of Geier v. Tennessee

Sometimes, the driest court records hold nuggets of narrative gold that can come to life through audio. Reporters Camellia Burris and Emily Siner made that case when they visited Vanderbilt Law School on September 22 to discuss “The Debt: What Tennessee Owes Its HBCU,” a podcast from Nashville Public Radio and the Tennessee Lookout. Burris and Siner explained how they turned the 1968 case Geier v. Tennessee and its legacy into a true story with plot, stakes, and characters. They drew on firsthand accounts, archival tape, and narrative scripting to tell the story of Tennessee State University’s fight for fair funding.

The reporters were introduced by Daniel Sharfstein, Dick and Martha Lansden Chair in Law and Director of the George Barrett Social Justice Program, which hosted the event. Camellia Burris, an attorney and journalist from Nashville, covers education for WPLN News. She is a graduate of Spelman College, Tulane University School of Law, and the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism; she previously reported for the San Francisco Public Press and Miami Herald. Emily Siner, a Pulitzer finalist and Peabody Award-winning story editor, was executive producer of WNYC Studios’ More Perfect and news director of Nashville Public Radio. She has also produced and edited episodes of NPR’s Planet Money and Vox’s Unexplainable.

The Project Began in a Vanderbilt Law School Classroom

Siner said the project started when she audited Professor Sharfstein’s course on the legal history of race, where she encountered Geier v. Tennessee, the case about desegregating Tennessee’s public higher education system.

Every Southern state, Siner explained, had a flagship land-grant university that excluded Black students, along with at least one land-grant university created to educate Black students. In Tennessee, those were the University of Tennessee and Tennessee State University (“TSU”). Years after Brown v. Board of Education, the two schools remained effectively segregated: the University of Tennessee remained white and well-funded, while TSU remained Black and poorly funded.

In 1968, Rita Sanders Geier ’70, a Vanderbilt Law student who was also teaching at TSU, brought a suit. With Vanderbilt Law alumnus George Barrett, for whom she was clerking, she argued that the state had an affirmative duty to desegregate. The case focused on the University of Tennessee’s growing Nashville campus, which would compete with TSU for funding. The case lasted 38 years before settling in 2006, making it, Siner said, the longest-running higher education desegregation case in the country.

Filling Gaps in the Court Record through Journalism

A passing reference in a 1979 decision to an alleged effort to oust TSU’s president sent Siner looking for what the court record omitted. She explained that court decisions are narrow by design and rarely capture the stories behind the people or conflict in a case. To fill those gaps, she relied on news archives, including Tennessean archives, which are available for free through the Tennessee State Library, and interviews.

Those interviews led her to George Pruitt, a former TSU administrator who had written a book about the era. Pruitt described how Dr. Frederick Humphries, a chemist who became TSU’s president, refused to accept the state’s plan for two competing universities in Nashville. In a podcast clip played during the event, Pruitt recounted Humphries’ response when state officials pressed him to fall in line: complying would betray the university and the Black Tennesseans it served, and “given the choices, I’d rather take the consequences.”

Burris added that a 1984 settlement to improve TSU’s facilities came with a condition that TSU stop calling itself a Black university. Humphries’ son shared that the decision was painful for his father, who later left to become president of Florida A&M University, another HBCU.

A Father’s Report Resurfaced

Burris traced the case’s modern chapter to State Representative Harold Love, Jr., a TSU alumnus whose father had also served as a state representative. After TSU’s Dean of Agriculture asked Representative Love for help securing the university’s state matching funds, Representative Love found that, for many years, the state had budgeted nothing for TSU while always budgeting money for the University of Tennessee, Knoxville.

As a junior lawmaker with little political power, Representative Love struggled to get colleagues on board. Then he found a 1970 legislative report among boxes from his father’s office. It showed that TSU had received $51,600 of the $4.5 million in federal land-grant funds given to Tennessee that year. “Wow, this is exactly what I need,” Love recalled in a clip from the podcast. In 2016, he held up his father’s report on the floor of the Tennessee House.

Later, Tennessee House Speaker Cameron Sexton met with Black lawmakers to discuss where the state was falling short, and Representative Love pointed to TSU’s land-grant funding. Siner said the state calculated the debt at $544 million, and the governor budgeted $250 million, “a big amount of money, although not actually close to the amount that they came up with,” Siner noted.

Unresolved History Keeps Resurfacing

When asked whether the issue could ever become a national litigation effort, Burris said Representative Love has spoken with lawmakers in other states about similar efforts and that she hopes others will follow suit. Siner noted Representative Love’s view that working through the legislature can be more effective than litigation, pointing to a recent settlement in Maryland where each HBCU received less than $250 million after legal fees and a split among several schools.

Since receiving the $250 million, TSU has “blossomed,” Burris said, reducing its budget deficit by $13.5 million and appearing to turn around, though it is still owed more than $100 million. However, Siner noted, the history shows that “if it’s never fully resolved, it just keeps bubbling up in every generation.” And as political tides shift, she added, the issue may fade, but it never actually goes away.

On what drew the two journalists to this project, Siner shared, “I’m really drawn to things that help us understand our current moment and how we got here.” She pointed to a TSU building in downtown Nashville, once part of UT Nashville’s campus, that was turned over to TSU as part of the court-ordered remedy. Burris, a Spelman College graduate with family and friends who attended TSU, said her motivation was personal.

Recent News