When the Sixth Amendment was ratified in 1791, guaranteeing the right to a “speedy and public trial,” [1] the Framers hardly could have imagined just how public these trials have become in the age of social media. These days, public trials, especially high-profile criminal trials, are broadcast all over social media.[2] It’s no new concern that the rise in social media coverage creates conflict between essential constitutional rights.[3] For example, most of the existing literature has focused on the tension between the right of a criminal defendant to a public trial and the right of a criminal defendant to a fair trial.[4] However, there is increasingly a concern over not just the rights of the defendant, but the rights of jurors.[5] And, ultimately, this effect of social media on jurors only compounds the concerns over a fair trial, especially in the context of mistrials.
In the recent trial of Lindsay Clancy, a jury was asked to determine whether Clancy was legally responsible for the killings of her three children, or whether she was mentally ill (from postpartum psychosis) such that the law could not hold her criminally responsible.[6] The trial garnered substantial coverage online and across social media platforms.[7] Coverage ranged from conspiracy theories that her husband actually killed the children to posts raising awareness about postpartum psychosis.[8] Substantial controversy stemmed from the defense’s argument that the healthcare system had failed Clancy.[9] Coverage was so prevalent and polarizing that at one point over four hundred protestors gathered outside the courthouse during the proceedings to show support for Clancy.[10]
On September 4, the trial ended in a mistrial, as a result of a hung jury.[11] Before the mistrial was declared, jury notes revealed that the jury was split eleven to one, indicating a sole holdout juror.[12] Defense counsel, based on additional jury notes, argued that this holdout juror had admitted that he had a reasonable doubt about Clancy’s guilt, and yet refused to apply the law—the law which mandates that reasonable doubt results in a not-guilty finding.[13] All of this information was available online, available through the livestream of the courtroom proceedings themselves, and discussed across social media platforms.[14] In fact, even the identity of the holdout juror, despite being sealed by the Court, was discovered through “photos published online, court records and an interview with one of his fellow jurors.”[15] As a result, the holdout juror has received substantial backlash online.[16] The backlash has gone so far that the juror, his family, and his workplace have received threats.[17]
While the context of the holdout juror allegedly not following the law is arguably unique, this issue nevertheless raises broader questions and concerns about the impact of social media on jurors’ rights and a defendant’s right to a fair trial. For example, is a juror’s right to privacy still intact when the online community is able to piece together their identity? Will potential social media exposure and backlash create an increased desire to evade jury summons? Additionally, what does this mean for the possibility of a fair trial for the defendant? This heightened fear of public exposure for jury members could create a perverse incentive to appease the public when rendering a verdict, especially in mistrial situations where public opinion is strong and widely dispersed before a new jury has even been selected. In order to address this growing concern, courts may need to reevaluate the balancing of the rights to a public trial and freedom of press with the rights to privacy and a fair trial.
Fiona Saunders is a 2L at Vanderbilt Law School from Wilmington, DE. She is focused on litigation. She spent her 1L summer at Abrams & Bayliss in Wilmington and will spend her 2L summer at Choate Hall & Stewart in Boston.
[1] U.S. Const. amend. XI.
[2] See Taylor Burton, Rise of the Armchair Detective: The Impact of Social Media on Court Cases, Pa. Bar Inst. (Sept. 24, 2025), https://www.pbi.org/blog/rise-of-the-armchair-detective-the-impact-of-social-media-on-court-cases/.
[3] See Ryan Fenn, This Isn’t a Reality Show: How Social Media Livestreams of High-Profile Criminal Trials May Violate One’s Right to a Fair Trial, 96 St. John’s L. Rev. 789, 792 (2022).
[4] Id.
[5] See generally Jessica Lieb, Jurors Taking a Bullet, 23 Nw. J. Tech. & Intell. Prop. 415 (2026).
[6] See Marian Braccia, One Juror, No Verdict: What the Lindsay Clancy Mistrial Tells Us About Jury Unanimity, Voices at Temple Law (Sept. 9, 2026), https://www2.law.temple.edu/voices/lindsay-clancy-mistrial-jury-unanimity/.
[7] See Alexandra Miller, The Fierce Attention Directed at Lindsay Clancy’s Trial Highlights Risks About Truth and Social Media, Scripps News (Aug. 20, 2026), https://www.scrippsnews.com/us-news/crime/the-fierce-attention-directed-at-lindsay-clancys-trial-highlights-risks-about-truth-and-social-media.
[8] Id.
[9] See Deborah Becker & Ayesha Rascoe, Why Hundreds Showed Up to Support Murder Trial Defendant Lindsay Clancy, NPR (Aug. 23, 2026), https://www.npr.org/2026/08/23/nx-s1-5940882/why-hundreds-showed-up-to-support-murder-trial-defendant-lindsay-clancy.
[10] Id.
[11] See Braccia, supra note 6.
[12] Id.
[13] Id.
[14] See Leah Willingham, WATCH: Judge Sends Deadlocked Lindsay Clancy Jury Back After Defense Seeks 1 Juror’s Removal, PBS NewsHour (Sept. 3, 2026), https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/watch-live-lindsay-clancy-jury-continues-deliberations-as-mistrial-chances-grow.
[15] See Nicki Brown, Alex Stambaugh, Alisha Ebrahimji & Rebekah Riess, 2 Weeks After the End of Lindsay Clancy’s Trial, the Holdout Juror Comes Forward and Patrick Clancy Speaks Out, CNN (Sept. 18, 2026), https://www.cnn.com/2026/09/17/us/clancy-juror-holdout-statement-hnk.
[16] See Nicholas Bogel-Burroughs, Holdout Juror in Lindsay Clancy Case Says He Didn’t Doubt Her Guilt, N.Y. Times (Sept. 18, 2026), https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/18/us/lindsay-clancy-trial-holdout-juror.html.
[17] See Nicole Moder, Online Threats, Scrutiny of Lindsay Clancy Jurors Raise Concerns After Mistrial, NBC 10 News (Sept. 18, 2026), https://turnto10.com/news/local/online-threats-scrutiny-of-lindsay-clancy-jurors-raise-concerns-after-mistrial-jury-social-media-pressure-negative-identity-exposed-september-18-2026.